The 'Shutup and Be Happy' Debate

| 1 Comment | 0 TrackBacks


I think we have about 4 generations left

I am not shouting this.  But I think it may be so.  And I know most will ignore my Jerimiahed screed.

Humans have about 4 generations left on this planet.  Not much more. 

That puts it into the next century. There are plenty of serious climate model scenarios described out to the year 2100.  Some are not so bad, some are horrible.  Even the more optimistic views are predicated on very radical changes to our civilization to fight this.  Something we are not doing in the slightest.  Not even started. No real plans. As David Letterman said recently about global warming, “We are so screwed”   

So We Humans are pretty much doomed, but not Us Humans now. Right now everything is pretty nice.  Beautiful summer, plenty to eat, and for the most part, skies are clear and cool.  . But climate destabilization is so great, and carries such momentum, that we have long passed our opportunity to effect change.  Now, today all we can say is Adapt, Mitigate and Accept.


I really don’t want to stand on the corner in a hair shirt and sandals preaching doom.  Nobody wants to hear it.  No one wants to spoil the party. And it is not fun for me.  Some want to stay oblivious for fun, some for profit, and some because they really cannot face it.  Many, many know it, but carry on with civil grace, social acceptability, and economic momentum.

The internal debate I hold is about how I let that affect my life today.  Since I am 59 years old, I may not be facing much of the big problems that the future generations will be facing. We might figure that our grandchildren will be living in a world that we cannot even imagine  - if they are lucky.  What do I owe them in preparing and warning and accepting?   If I cannot really change much, shouldn’t I just shutup and be happy?


I suspect this is a very big debate.  Philosophical, existentialist, grief and everything you want to think about applies here.  A much better debate, I think than anything else.


No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.climatedebatedaily.org/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rpauli/managed-mt/mt-tb.cgi/17

1 Comment

If we are genuinely concerned about our grandchildren and realize it's no longer "business as usual," for the human race, we'd be well advised to learn, and then teach, the skills "civilization" has all but forgotten: farming, hunting, gathering, weaving, etc. All the skills humans relied on for so many generations before fossil fuel took their place.

Recent Entries

Seismic activity linked to global warming
Finally, human civilization is starting to get global warming events that it can FEEL.   Earthquakes, tsunamis, and volcanoes.  …
Should science set global warming policy ?
Science defines global warming so well, and science can tell us how to best mitigate the problem What is the…
New debate - treachery or delusion?
Here's a debate:  Is AGW denialism treachery or delusion? Global warming is unfolding faster than expected.CO2 makes global warming worse,…
New debate: Hopeful or Doomed?
The answer is both: the day breaks both to doom and a hopeful dawn. A good friend writes of his…
CO2 effects well into the year 3000
And our children’s children cannot escape it either. Even if we suddenly halted all CO2 and reverted to the pure…
Behavioral Economics Ultimatum Game
The Ultimatum Game is a deceptively simple test of human economic attitude. It goes like this:   The experimenter tells…
Humans shall persist and thrive - Pro or Con?
Crazy is doing the same thing over-and-over and expecting a different result.    Climatedebatedaily.com continues crazy postings trying to establish and…
Just up ahead...
Now we are in the midst of crafting our long term economy while adjusting to the ravages of a…
Argues with Idiots
That would be my Indian name.   Argues-with-Idiots.  I am tilting at the windmill of human denial about the danger of…
Looming Heat Storm Has No End
Humans have decided to accept the risk of certain warming in exchange for easy, cheap carbon fuels.   Of course, mass…
Understanding Ourselves - thanks Wikipedia
Wikipedia can save the world through helping us understand ourselves better Some human traits work to block progress in facing…
How bad? and When? Answer: Worse and Sooner
I try to avoid expressing my hypervigilance much  - but this may be appropriate.  Global warming is totally ignored.  Global…